| Name | Fastest 800 meter time | Fastest 800 Meter relay split | Fastest 400 meter | Fastest 1600 meter | Fastest Junior 800 | Fastest Soph 800 | Fastest Frosh 800 | Are they in HOF | VCP time | Did they jump | Coach | College and time | Where did they live in high school | Grad Year | |
| Thomas Carroll | 1:49.2m 7/31/57 | 50.7 | 04:29.2 | 1:58 | 02:02.2 | yes | 13:58 | no | Fox | Yale | Washington Heights | 1957 | |||
| Reynaldo Mendez | 1:51.9m 5/15/93 | 01:53.4 | 49.8 | 04:13.8 | 01:55.0 | 01:57.6 | 2:07 | no | 12:33.7 | Long jump | Febles | William and Mary 1:50 | Bronx | 1993 | |
| James DeRienzo | 01:53.0 | 01:53.4 | 50.6 | 4:25 | 01:59.2 | 2:45 | DNR hamstring tear | yes | 13:17 | long jump | Miller | Fordham/ Georgetown 1:47.06 | Westchester | 1975 | |
| Brian Doherty | 1:54.3m 5/6/06 | 01:52.7 | 49.1 | 04:35.1 | 01:56.4 | 01:56.5 | 2:06 | no | 14:05 | Long jump/Pole vault | Febles | St. Joes 1:56 training slowed hit by car | Westchester | 2006 | |
| Jose Fernandez | 1:54.96m 5/10/03 | 01:55.5 | 49.9 | 04:48.0 | 01:56.7 | 02:01.9 | 02:13.6 | no | 13:52.0 | no | Febles | Northeastern | Riverdale | 2003 | |
| Eugene Pabst | 1:55.8 1960 | no | 14:12 | no | Fox | 1960 | |||||||||
| John Hemsley | 1:57.0 1977 | 1:53 | 50.8 | 4:16 | DNR 800 | 2:05 | DNR Played basketball | yes | 12:54 | no | Miller | Iona DNR | Bronx | 1977 | |
| Michael Cleary | 1:57.4 1979 | 1:53 | DNR | 4:14 | DNR 800 | 02:02.6 | 02:08.4 | yes | 12:47 | no | Miller/Laurino | Iona 1:50 | Riverdale | 1979 | |
| Idris Payne | 1:57.3m 5/19/01 | 01:59.5 | 49.5 | 04:48.1 | 01:58.6 | 02:09.4 | 02:21.7 | no | 14:28 | Triple jump/High jump | Febles | Northeastern | Manhattan | 2001 | |
| Matthew Keefer | 1:57.65m 4/14/07 | 01:58.5 | 49.8 | 4:53 | 01:58.5 | 2:11 | DNR 800 and played baseball, football | no | 14:58 | Triple jump | Febles | Tufts | Westchester | 2007 | |
| Brian McCabe | 1:57.80m 5/31/04 | 01:53.7 | 51.2 | 04:14.0 | 01:59.9 | 02:00.2 | 02:06.6 | no | 12:50.7 | no | Febles | American | Westchester | 2004 | |
| Michael Nahon | 1:59.2 1970 | 01:53.7 | 51.4 | DNR 1600 | 01:56.5 | DNR | 2:09 | yes | 14:10 | no | Byrne | Fordham 1:52.8 | Bronx | 1970 | |
| Robert Anastasio | 1:59.2 1970 | 01:52.8 | 04:16.6 | yes | 13:16 | no | Byrne | Cornell 1:47 | Bronx | 1970 | |||||
| Andy Stadnik | 1:59.4 1976 | 01:56.7 | 49.6 | DNR 1600 | 01:59.3 | 2:04 | 2:15 | no | 15:13 | no | Miller | Cornell DNR | Bethpage | 1977 | |
| Robert Weitzman | 1:58.8m 5/20/95 | 01:59.2 | 48.6 | DNR | 02:02.1 | 02:09.0 | no | DNR | no | Febles | Fordham | Riverdale | 1996 | ||
| Daryn Johnson | 1:58.8m 4/18/98 | 01:56.3 | 52 | 04:23.9 | 01:56.8 | 02:11.2 | 02:07.2 | no | 13:17.9 | Triple jump/long jump | Febles | Cornell 1:56.3 | Harlem | 1999 | |
| Conrad Dalton | 1:58.8m 5/5/02 | 01:53.7 | 48.2 | DNR 1600 | 01:55.6 | 02:02.6 | 02:18.5 | no | DNR | High jump | Febles | Northeastern | Bronx | 2003 | |
| Edwin Wheeler | 1:59.6 5/31/53 | 02:12.2 | no | no | Fox | 1953 | |||||||||
| Peter McIntosh | 1:59.0m 1960 | 04:27.2 | yes | 13:54 | no | Fox | Notre Dame DNR severed achilles | 1960 | |||||||
| Neil McCarthy | 01:59.9 | no | no | Fox | Fordham | 1953 | |||||||||
| Todd Young | 1:59.5m 6/1/97 | 01:59.6 | 53.7 | 4:23 | 02:02.1 | 02:05.3 | 02:10.1 | no | 13:33 | no | Febles | Binghamton | Westchester | 1997 | |
| Jim Lundy | 1:59.99m 5/21/05 | 02:03.6 | 53.1 | 4:29 | 01:59.9 | 02:04.3 | 02:23.9 | no | 13:42.8 | no | Febles | Holy Cross | Westchester | 2005 | |
| Dan Doherty | 01:59.7 | 01:59.7 | 50.22 | DNR | DNR 800 | DNR 800 | DNR 800 | no | DNR | long jump/Triple jump/pole vault | Febles | Villanova | Westchester | 2004 | |
| Greg Sans | 01:55.8 | 01:55.8 | 50.72 | 4:43 | 01:58.9 | 02:03.0 | 02:06.8 | no | DNR | long jump/high jump | Febles | George Washington | Westchester | 2004 | |
| Fred Miller | 1:57 | 01:56.9 | 47.9 | 4:28 | 1:59 | 2:02 | DNR 800 | yes | 13:45 | long jump | Byrne | Fordham 1:53.2 | Throggs Neck | 1969 | |
| Brian Faraci | 04:21.4 | 02:06.1 | yes | 12:40.2 | no | Byrne/Tobias | Lehigh | Rockland County | 1972 | ||||||
| Des Sugrue | 01:58.8 | 1:58 | 04:29.2 | 1:58 | yes | 13:22 | no | Byrne | Upenn | Riverdale | 1970 | ||||
| John Doyle | 01:57.5 | 02:06.6 | no | 14:11 | no | Byrne | Bronx | 1970 | |||||||
| Terrence Egan | 1:56 | 1:56 | 52 | 4:22 | 1:59 | 1:59 | 2:15 | no | 13:32 | High jump | Febles | Notre Dame 1:58 injured majority of freshman year | Westchester | 2006 | |
| John Bradley | 1:57 | 1:57 | 51.9 | 4:18 | 1:58 | 1:59 | 2:11 | no | 13:04 | no | Febles | Villanova DNR | Westchester | 2006 | |
| Zach Bordonaro | 01:59.2 | 01:59.2 | 57.2 | 04:44.1 | 02:08.9 | 02:07.6 | 02:18.5 | no | 13:53.4 | no | Febles | Tufts DNR | Westchester | 2006 | |
| Deric Zaphire | 01:56.9 | 01:56.9 | 50.4 | 4:43 | 02:00.6 | 02:09.8 | 2:15 | no | 14:06 | Febles | Fordham | Coop City | 1999 | ||
| Dave Fernandez | 01:59.9 | 01:59.9 | 54.3 | 04:29.1 | 02:01.3 | 02:10.8 | 02:21.1 | no | 13:57 | High jump | Febles | Georgetown | Riverdale | 1999 | |
| Ramon German | 1:57 | no | Donnelly | Fordham 1:50 | 1986 | ||||||||||
| Pat Hemsley | 01:59.9 | 01:59.9 | 51.4 | 04:45.0 | 02:02.0 | 2:10 | 2:12 | no | 14:39 | Febles | Iona | Westchester | 2007 | ||
| Average | 01:57.4 | 01:56.5 | 50.962 | 04:28.9 | 01:59.0 | 02:04.8 | 02:10.5 | 13:41.4 | |||||||
| Name | Fastest 800 meter time | Fastest 800 Meter relay split | Fastest 400 meter | Fastest 1600 meter | Fastest Junior 800 | Fastest Soph 800 | Fastest Frosh 800 | Are they in HOF | VCP time | Did they jump | Coach | College and time | Where did they live in high school | Grad Year | |